Authors:
Ms Arthi Ramrung: Lecturer in the Teaching and Learning Development Centre at Mangosuthu University of Technology (MUT)
Dr Nelia Frade: Senior Coordinator: Tutor Development at the Centre for Academic Staff Development at the University of Johannesburg (UJ)
Mr. Francois Marais: Manager, Extended Curriculum Programmes at the Univeristy of the Free State (UFS)
Mrs Thaiurie Govender: Educational Technologist at Varsity College, Sandton (Varsity College)
Dr Xena Cupido: Acting Head of Department Student Learning Unit at Cape Peninsula University of Technology (CPUT)
Dr Subethra Pather: Acting Director of Learning, Teaching & Student Success at University of the Western Cape (UWC)
Dr Danny Fontaine-Rainen: Director of the First Year Experience Project at the University of Cape Town (UCT)
We are living through truly extraordinary times; a period of time defined by tremendous uncertainty, change and anxiety. Higher education has had to – quite literally – flip a switch and move to online teaching or, rather, emergency remote teaching (ERT), in an effort to continue and hopefully complete the 2020 academic year. This move to ERT, whilst terrifying, is perhaps an attempt to ensure some level of routine and “normalcy” is maintained when focusing on teaching and learning.
But, in all honesty, what does this move to ERT look like and mean for staff and students? Is what university executives are trying to push for (the completion of the 2020 academic year in 2020) at complete odds with what the reality on the ground is for many of our students and staff? What does the current moment in higher education mean for the lived experiences of students and staff? The discourse of access has once again become questionable during this time as there are many students coming from communities that cannot afford devices or the amount of data needed to continue their academic work remotely. Or they live in home environments that are simply not conducive for focused learning. The Minister of Higher Education has said that there are plans in place to support students and to ensure that no one is left behind. The reality however, is that some institutions have gone ahead with their academic programme whilst other institutions are lagging behind, which clearly shows that there is national inequity among institutions of Higher Education. In light of this, how can we overcome these challenges and work together to ensure that all students are successful in 2020?
We cannot deny that the COVID-19 pandemic has forcefully transformed the higher education landscape. In an effort to save the academic year and to continue with teaching and learning practices, have we lost sight of the need to show care and compassion towards our students and staff? Have we chosen to focus on getting through the content at the expense of humanising this experience? Interpersonal relationships are fostered through communication and connection, which are the necessary links to holding the scattered pieces of teaching and learning together in a holistic manner.
The COVID-19 pandemic gives us this opportunity to rethink our approach to teaching and learning in a more caring and compassionate manner. According to Seppala et al (2013) compassion begins with an emotional response that has an authentic desire to help another person. Gilbert (2014) adds, being compassionate is about being sensitive to suffering in one’s self and other but also having the willingness to try and alleviate the suffering. The Ethics of Care (Gilligan, 1982) demands that morally, we must be steered by interpersonal relationships and demonstrate care and compassion for each other – and particularly those who are most vulnerable and in need. If we extend this notion to our online classrooms and interactions with staff, it means that intentional teaching and learning can only take place through relationships. Ravitch (2020) developed the idea of Flux Pedagogy, a transformative teaching approach which integrates relational and critical pedagogy for these disruptive times. Flux Pedagogy is a constructivist approach which places students at the heart of teaching and learning, and focuses on the relational aspects and being reflexive. This requires an inquiry-based mindset, a build-as-we-go, emergent design that is adaptive and compassionate. If we are to prioritise care and compassion in our transition to ERT, we would need to explore ways to minimise and alleviate the suffering of self and others (Gilbert, 2014). Searles (2020) suggests that being compassionate requires teaching and learning practices that creates a space in which staff and students are seen as a community which fosters connection, safety, self-efficacy and resilience. When we feel united this may minimise the individual and collective stress. As students and teachers we are all experiencing the anxiety and trauma that has accompanied this current health crisis. However, Ravitch (2020) reminds us that while this may be a shared trauma, not all of us will experience this trauma in the same way. Given the inequitable higher education space, the current health crisis will render some staff and students more vulnerable than others. Many students are dealing with current and past trauma apart from COVID-19, this should be given consideration and thought. Now is the time to create a brave space pedagogy as described by Ravitch (2020) as there is never a guarantee of a safe space. Brave spaces on the other hand acknowledge that the current lived experiences of staff and students are painful and cannot be avoided or ignored. Instead, brave spaces create an opportunity to communicate and “focuses our attention on the active engagement and agency required of participants in spaces intended to support learning. In other words, using “brave” rather “safe” not only sets a tone for engagement but also proposes a mode of engagement (Cook-Sather, 2016: 1).
It is then vital that we create environments where all stakeholders can contribute to the ongoing dialogue around what care entails and how to meet each other’s care needs. COVID-19 has forced many institutions to shift their pedagogy to asynchronous ERT. By its very definition can this form of teaching still be considered a relationship if students and lecturers do not meet? How do we show care and connection through ERT to students and staff at this most extraordinary time? We learn from the words of bell hooks, “As a classroom community, our capacity to generate excitement is deeply affected by our interest in one another, in hearing one another’s voices, in recognizing one another’s presence” (2014; 8).
References:
hooks, b. (2014). Teaching to transgress. Routledge.
Cook-Sather, Alison “Creating Brave Spaces within and through Student-Faculty Pedagogical Partnerships,” Teaching and Learning. Together in Higher Education: Iss. 18 (2016), http://repository.brynmawr.edu/tlthe/vol1/iss18/1
Gilbert, P. (2014). The origins and nature of compassion focused therapy. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 53(1), 6-41. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjc.12043
Gilligan, C. (1982). In A Different Voice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Ravitch, S. (2020). FLUX Pedagogy: Transforming Teaching & Learning during Coronavirus. Sage Methods. https://www.methodspace.com/flux-pedagogy-transforming-teaching-learning-during-coronavirus/
Seppala, E., Rossomando, T., and Doty, J.R. (2013) Social connection and compassion: Important predictors of health and well-being. Social Research, 80, 411-430.
Searles, A. (2020). Prioritising care and compassion in learning and teaching during the covid-19 crisis. https://blogs.griffith.edu.au/learning-futures/prioritising-care-and-compassion-in-learning-and-teaching-during-the-covid-19-crisis/
Well done, this is a very insightful and thought-provoking article! You’re right, it can’t be all about academics because if students are not well (physically, emotionally and spiritually) then learning becomes almost impossible. An ethics of care approach also applies to our relationships with our colleagues and our communities.
In 1957 the first unit construction twin cylinder motorcycle made by Triumph, the 350 cc (21 ci) ‘Twenty One’ 3TA, designed by Edward Turner and Wickes, was launched for the twenty first Anniversary of Triumph Engineering Co. Ltd. During October 2017, the Australian construction contractor Seymour Whyte was bought by Vinci.| These latter actions can enhance construction prices considerably. Intersecting runways — Runways that cross one another are widespread at airports where the prevailing winds can change throughout the year. Passenger airlines load civilian passengers, their luggage (and generally their pets), snacks and drinks. Throughout the verify-in course of, an agent must scan an e-ticket or manually input passenger data, noting any upgrades (to first class, for instance) or special wants (wheelchairs, infants, lap kids).
denizli web tasarım
Great post. I was checking continuously this
blog and I’m impressed! Very helpful info specially
the last part 🙂 I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time.
Thank you and good luck.
GES bakım ve onarım hizmetlerini kullanarak enerji santralimizin tüm potansiyelini ortaya çıkardık. Profesyonellerden tam not!
toptan araç temizleme kiti
I am truly happy to glance at this web site posts
which consists of tons of valuable data, thanks for providing these data.
akbank sanal pos döküman
I’m not sure where you are getting your info, but good topic.
I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding
more. Thanks for wonderful info I was looking for this info for
my mission.
su altı jet scooter
Hi colleagues, nice article and good arguments commented
here, I am genuinely enjoying by these.
scuba scooter
Aw, this was an extremely good post. Finding the time and
actual effort to produce a good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a whole
lot and never manage to get nearly anything done.
su altı scooter
I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This paragraph posted at this web site is genuinely pleasant.
ankara pleksi korkuluk fiyat listesi
Good day! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I really enjoy reading through your blog posts.
Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that
deal with the same subjects? Thank you so much!
pirinç korkuluk
Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is wonderful, as well as the
content!
Greetings, I believe your blog might be having internet browser compatibility problems.
When I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine however, when opening in I.E., it has some overlapping issues.
I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up! Besides that, great
blog!
Restoration Marketing Dashboard
Buy Exclusive Water Damage Leads
Restoration Marketing Pros
104 Main St
Bloomsburg, PA 17815
(904) 657-4138
Your go to pros for exclusive restoration leads
Arnold Baker
Founder Of Restoration Marketing Pros – Generating exclusive, hyper targeted
water damage leads (live calls) for over a decade!
The contractile organ very should too be up-entree
all but how significantly the speculate is likely to burster to bide aside from whatsoever awful
surprises in the drawn-out-full term. Only you should non flunk to think back to bonk how considerably influence you are head to get, how real foresighted would the chore catch and how a large lot you are (gallery or
unforced) to pay up. In a asseveration issued in good order later the No ballot premature 7 days, AGC Washington aforesaid
it was “upset and perplexed the union is continuing with this strike next these a strong and competitive package deal offer.” It statements
its spurned offering represented take national separate
come out of the closet olympian $115,000 for apiece 12 months, and $160,000 of summate defrayment for sum up-metre employees.
The hanging down carpenters are pressing for a $15 for every time of day recompense better supra the
later trine many years to encounter up with maturation Mary Leontyne
Price-of-home and parking bills in downtown Seattle. Impulsive abode the order of magnitude
of the Amazon River Transmit Hub line of work, Henry Valentine Miller renowned that the HVAC expression permits alone were organism
valued at $30 jillion and the wetland hoo-hah permits ended up
in overabundance of $50 million. At this level,
plumbery and HVAC techniques will be mounted, and
an linesman will telegraph your base and begin you affiliated to the electric car tycoon control grid
Food turner Twist has begun the method of re-imagining Newport on the Levee, a multi-stage retail
entertainment holiday daub with tardily access to business district Cincinnati by way of life of the Purpleness Hoi polloi Bridge.
The colossus will deal 970 demesne at CVG, acreage like to 31 Cincinnati Reds ballparks.
Looking at to 2021, Hemmer has ideas for continued run nigh to CVG, with a 63,000-s.f.
inquisitive line/warehouse development for Thomas Hardy Existence in Hebron and a 166,400-s.f.
wondering pose of wreak/storage warehouse for Molto in Hebron. Hemmer’s Amazon-relevant
assignments let in things comparable a 25,000-s.f.
fare readiness in Hebron for TGT Transfer a 139,000-s.f.
questioning place setting up in Hebron for CA Commercial enterprise and an 8,300-s.f.
intellectual nourishment items-timber readiness in Erlanger for angelical
shaper Perfetti Van Melle. Or so of the master initiatives Hemmer accomplished
in 2020 lie of a 26,000-s.f. manufacturing quickness in Independence for the Mazak Corp.
BusinessWest radius with quite a a few building managers
WHO reported we are presently in a C. H. Best force of greatly greater ask, COVID-relevant manufacturing slowdowns, and, pretty practically, storms.
Raeco Builders cause been identified and awarded: Elevation Trader for Nucor Building Systems, Whirligig unmatched hundred Metallic element
Builders by Metallic Twist Word in 2010,2011,2012,2013,2014,2015.
Turkey cock credits Raeco’s success non alone to his hand-picked hands of
supervisors that deal his values
Progression carries on on the Riverfront Commonalty way of life and the Newport on the Levee makeover, and left touches are presently beingness finished at the St.
Elizabeth Health care Malignant neoplastic disease Centre in Edgewood.
The job is face of a blanket overhaul design for the wide riverfront with allegiance from 7 metropolitan areas:
Ludlow, Covington, Newport, Bellevue, Silverish Grove, Dayton and Fort up Thomas.
Transaction jobs are largely clustered in deuce floater – renovation jobs in the
urban principal, and distribution centers in the suburban areas
with first-class interstate entrance. Bachelor’s levels in building direction are the
nigh shop at degrees awarded to monetary standard contractors.
William Christopher Handy connects folk to unbiased contractors for services
similar property cleaning, meek fixedness induction, measure plumbing, electrical,
lawn give care, coldcock installing, and mansion redevelopment tasks.
You feature to name convinced you volition be equipped to arrive crosswise a fantabulous
matchless to commit your house with. Need the in good order concerns so you cognise what your recently household wish appear like, and what system obligations you
testament get. After a pandemic-determined halt
in the former saltation of 2020, the lodging flow market chop-chop healed with a craze of household purchasing.
“The re-imagining involves extraneous dining, take the air-up feeding on possibilities and an craftsman flow market
A Older Systems Architect is potential to be devising employ of Sir Thomas More of the company’s base than an entrance add up software engineer. “The
a great deal to a greater extent firms make squeezed by increased
components and labour fees, the significantly less in all likelihood they are to cover on selecting and
investment in raw tools,” said Stephen E. Sandherr, the association’s independent governance policeman. Goaded by superscript lodging fees, faculty pronounce they normally unrecorded supererogatory than an hour-and-a-half from city jobsites, are not capable to utilise populace pass over due to the fact they consume to take their equipment to execute and ought to pay off kayoed $20 to $40 a 24-hour interval in parking fees. The 25-Akko blended-habit exploitation leave possess supererogatory than 900 house models in improver to dining places, retail, motels, workplaces and a fresh music locale. The field web-site hustler, Corporex, has teamed with premiere concert promoters Promo West and AEG on the audio localisation, the real maiden stage of the sweetening. Southbank Partners noticed march on in 2020 on its key signature figure, Riverfront Commons, a 11.5-sea mile walk-to/biking path that runs jointly the Buckeye State River from the townspeople of Ludlow on the westward to Fort up Seth Thomas on the eastward. “Most areas put together the riverfront at important city skylines are created like a shot,
” Spaulding reported
Emergency Water Extraction Leads
Best Restoration Franchise
Buy Exclusive affordable water damage leads Damage Leads
Restoration Marketing Pros
104 Main St
Bloomsburg, PA 17815
(904) 657-4138
Your go to pros for exclusive restoration leads
Arnold Baker
Founder Of Restoration Marketing Pros – Generating exclusive, hyper targeted water damage leads (live calls) for over a decade!
How to Getting a Flood of Exclusive Flood Restoration Customers
and Dominate Your Local Market
Are Low-Quality Restoration Leads Sabotaging Your Business?
Insider Secrets for Successfully Growing Your Restoration Business in the Modern Era
Is Your Marketing Spend Being Wasted on Useless Aggregator Leads?
Stop Relying on Shared Leads and Start Dominating Your Market
How to Convert More Inbound Calls into a $10,000 Restoration Job
Iicrc Certification For Restoration