HELTASA’s Digital Teaching and Learning Project Team facilitated their second Digital Dialogue on Wednesday 27 July 2022. As with the first dialogue, this session was well attended with over 50 participants across a range of South African higher education institutions. The first Digital Dialogue in May was prompted by the question “What’s happening digitally at your institution now?” (read the key takeaways here), the focus for the second was on digital inequalities and emergent strategies in higher education. This involved a facilitated emergent strategies process, drawing on participants’ collective agency to share incremental steps towards change and thereby, reshaping our relationships with change.
Digital Inequalities
In addressing the challenges of the digital divide, and how these challenges mirror the inequalities within society, the guest speaker for the dialogue, Dr Najma Aghardien from the University of the Witwatersrand, highlighted the varying levels of access related to participation, digital skills and improved learning. This demonstrated how the digital divide is a social problem. Considering papers related to digital inequalities such as A Wake-Up Call: Equity, Inequality and Covid-19 Emergency Remote Teaching and Learning and ‘Deeply and deliciously unsettled’? Mis-reading discourses of equity in the early stages of Covid19, Dr Aghardien extracted the emerging themes from each paper. One theme was the assumption that staff and students are digitally fluid and how this could pose a threat to student success given the tendency to replicate “chalk and talk” methods online. Other themes demonstrated how some of the existing inequalities were amplified during the Covid-19 period and how the lack of guidance by national higher education structures exposed some vulnerabilities among staff and students. Thus, the digital divide creates an entanglement with other challenges. Lastly, the issue of agency and communication was crucial for learning and deep engagement and its presence or not during emergency remote learning and teaching. Dr Aghardien concluded with the following questions:
- How can we counteract digital inequalities to ensure a just representation of all knowledge(s) and/or people (lives/livelihoods)?
- What are some equitable actions that can get us to a culture of trust and care in a remote learning environment for students?
- How might ICT integration foster Personal Learning Communities to better prepare students for their various roles in society/world of work and beyond?
Emergent strategies
The Digital Learning and Teaching team then facilitated a session drawing on a presentation by Karen Costa at MYFest22 entitled “Re-imaging Higher Education”. The workshop drew heavily from the work of Adrienne Maree Brown. An emergent strategies process encourages us to reimagine and reframe our relationship with change so that we can shape change rather than only being shaped by change. We often look at massive problems in our institutions, feel very small, and then feel like there’s nothing we can do to change things, which can be demotivating. The emergent strategy process encourages us to recognise a holistic future where our small actions do matter and can create changes in the system.
The process yielded many rich and interesting ideas. Some of these were:
- A shared understanding of the greater good: Given the complexities in the world, there appears to be a shared understanding of what people would like to see for humanity in the future. It is a future filled with hope and one that is alive with possibilities.
- A shared vision for higher education: A shared vision for higher education that takes into consideration some of the challenges that impact digital inequalities. These include digital literacies, quality learning and teaching, a culture of care, collaboration, creativity, accessibility and open-mindedness.
- A view of contested spaces: Concerns around widening access, equal access to resources, employability and collaboration are still contested spaces in higher education and play a huge role in compounding challenges related to digital inequalities and social justice.
What is important in the emergent strategy process is the focus on the next step that each of us can take to move towards our envisaged shared future.
Yo, just checked out bet29. Pretty slick site, easy to navigate. Odds seem decent. Gonna throw a few bucks down and see what happens. Fingers crossed! Good luck to all out there!
Alright, gave a18bets a shot. The sportsbook is pretty comprehensive, lots of options. Depositing was smooth, which is always a plus. Hope the withdrawals are just as easy! Will update if I win big!
Okay, trying out 122betvip. Feeling like a VIP already! The deposit bonuses are pretty nice, but make sure to read the terms and conditions, guys. Good luck to all!! 🙂
Quick note: 91clublogingame’s login is pretty smooth. No problems so far. Check it out if you’re looking for a swift entry. It’s just 91clublogingame.
So i have come across a33clubgame, has anyone played before? please share your experience with me: a33clubgame
Weathernoho… Now that’s a specific one! Weather in NoHo? I’m checking this before my next trip! I’ll be equipped with the information I need when I visit! Check it out here: weathernoho
Опытные вебмастера используют раскрутка сайта хрумером https://www.olx.ua/d/uk/obyavlenie/progon-hrumerom-dr-50-po-ahrefs-uvelichu-reyting-domena-IDXnHrG.html, чтобы повысить видимость проекта.
Hey everyone! I stumbled upon g9777 and decided to check it out. It’s got a really nice, modern feel, and the games loaded quickly. Definitely worth adding to your list! Time to roll the dice! g9777
Iwin68iwin, gotta to say, the games are addicting. Been playing all day and got some luck my way. Definitely worth a few spins to relax iwin68iwin
Hey everyone, wanted to share my thoughts on jiliasia 888. I’ve been playing there for a bit and I’m enjoying it. It’s a solid choice with a decent selection. Give it a try: jiliasia 888
Lounge777, sounds fancy! Hoping the wins are worth it and the games are fun. Gotta check it out! Come play with me here: lounge777
Trying to get lucky logged in to 982betlogin. The login process could be smoother, but hey, if it pays out, who am I to complain Eh? 982betlogin
Downloaded the f12 app. Looks slick. Hoping for some good betting options and quick payouts. f12
Alright! time to see if f1688 lives up to the hype! Depositing a small amount to test the waters. Wish me luck everyone. f1688
Heard some buzz about 311jilipark. Sounds like a fun place to chill and maybe win some cash. Gonna give it a shot myself. Check it out at 311jilipark and let me know what you think!
Treating yourself? Jiliparkvip is supposed to be the high-roller experience. Saw some crazy bonuses online. If you’re feeling fancy, hit up jiliparkvip.
Alright lads, just had a go at xo so 666 on sclub88vip.com. Fingers crossed for a win next time! Check it out here: xo so 666
Mxgoldfishcasino, goldfish, eh? Probably means it’s bite-sized wins. Go find out: mxgoldfishcasino
Finally found a site that does not lag during peak hours. The bonuses are great and the customer service is very helpful. Love it! phsugarph
Best gaming experience so far. The registration process was so quick and I started winning right away. Give it a try guys! sugarph
The slots here are so exciting and the graphics are top notch. I really enjoy the variety of games they offer here. jilli777
This is exactly what we needed here in Ecuador. The local support is amazing and the odds are very competitive. I always choose 593ecuabet for my bets.
I love how straightforward everything is on this platform. No hidden fees or complicated rules just pure fun. I really like bdbcd33.
The mobile app version is way better than the browser one. It is fast and the games load instantly. You should definitely try jilievobdapp.
The app version is a game changer. It is so much more convenient to bet on the go without any glitches. Highly recommend downloading br393betapk
The lite version is exactly what I needed for my older phone. It runs perfectly without lagging at all. Get it at bingoplusliteappdownload.
Best experience so far! The interface is smooth and I didn’t encounter any lags during my session. Highly recommend kr5bet to everyone.
Honestly a hidden gem. The payout process is quicker than most platforms I have used before. If you are looking for reliability then 5k5k44 is the way to go.
I’ve been looking for a reliable spot and this one really delivers. The interface is smooth and everything loads quickly. Definitely worth a try! phjljl22
The betting options are huge and the live updates are very accurate. It is my go to site for sports and casino games. I trust vn855bet
I’ve tried a few sites lately but this one is actually smooth. The payouts are fast and the interface is very user friendly. Highly recommend phjili4 for anyone looking for a reliable spot.
I’ve tried a few platforms recently, but this one is definitely my favorite. The games load fast and the payouts are fair. Highly recommend phokjili for anyone looking for some real excitement!
Easy navigation and a wide range of games. I appreciate how stable the site is even during peak hours. Glad I found plus777comlink
Best platform for local players in my opinion. Everything feels very tailored to what we want. Visit ki888phcom for a great time.
Just hit a decent jackpot today! The slots here are fair and the graphics are amazing. Definitely give dragon212slot a try if you enjoy spinning.
Everything works perfectly on mobile. It is so convenient to play anywhere anytime with juanphlogin
Really impressed with the security and speed of this site. I had a few questions and the support team handled them instantly. Top notch service! 499batlogin
Best place for those who love quick wins and easy navigation. The login process is seamless and the graphics are top notch. Try jili666login now.
Vando88bet, eh? Gave it a whirl last week. The deposits were pretty quick which is always a plus. I won’t lie, didn’t hit the jackpot, but I wasn’t cleaned out either. It’s alright for a casual punt. Check it out for yourself, maybe you’ll have better luck: vando88bet
Finally found a platform that doesn’t lag during peak hours. The bonuses are actually fair and easy to claim. betbuss is my new go-to place.
Logging in is a breeze and I never face any glitches. It is the most stable app I have used so far. Just head over to bjbajiapplogin.
The login process is seamless and I had no issues setting up my account. It feels very secure and professional. I prefer using 20jililogin for my daily gaming.
The login process is seamless and I never have issues accessing my account. It is very stable compared to other sites. gbo303login is my go to place.
Great platform with a very professional feel. The promotions they offer are actually useful and easy to claim. Definitely give supermpologin a shot.
Solid experience so far. The community is helpful and the site layout is very intuitive. If you are looking for quality and reliability then brkk123 is the way to go.
Login is quick and the site is very stable. I didn’t encounter any lags even during peak hours. tania77login is definitely my new favorite spot.
Great vibes and even better prizes. I love how easy it is to navigate through the lobby. If you are looking for a win, try vn123wincasino.
Finally found a platform that feels honest and rewarding. The bonuses are actually useful and not just bait. I am sticking with vnw168 from now on.
I appreciate the transparency of this site. No hidden fees and the withdrawal process is straightforward. It is a reliable choice for anyone. zs88com
I have been loyal to this platform for months and the consistency never drops. Customer care is always available when I need help and the betting options cover everything I look for. It is the calm reliable choice in a busy market. Save your time and visit br777plus directly.
Super impressed with the bonus offers they provide for new players. It really gives you a head start. Visit inyoo777 for the best deals.
Really impressed with the layout and the variety of options here. It is easy to navigate and the rewards are great. plataformaboxwin is a solid choice for any player.
Honestly the best experience I have had in a while. The interface is smooth and the payouts are fast. Highly recommend idperangjitu to everyone.
Top tier service and the winning odds are actually decent. I really appreciate the transparency of this site. Join idboswin77 for a win.
Everything is running smoothly. I appreciate how stable the connection is when I use selayar88login to get into my account.
The bonuses for new players are actually worth it. I managed to double my first deposit easily. Visit br54bet1 for some awesome rewards.
The app installation was a breeze. No glitches and the graphics are top notch. Glad I decided to use newjilislotdownload.
I love how I can play on the go without any glitches. The app version is just perfect for my daily breaks. Cheers to kishphapp!
Quick access and no glitches. It is refreshing to find a site that actually prioritizes speed and stability for the players. nog88login
The login process is seamless and I love how quickly I can get into the action. Best slot experience I have had in a while. Just visit slotaladinlogin and see for yourself.
Such a friendly community and the rewards are actually generous. Loving my time on jililoveapp
Super reliable site. I’ve had some issues with other links before but this login page is stable and secure. Happy with the service at muliajitulogin.
This site has a really cool layout and the games load instantly. No more waiting around. Just visit pkbh999 and start winning.
Finally found a place where the app installs without any glitches. The loading speed is impressive and the gameplay is top-notch. Just get the yooe777download and start playing.
Finally found a spot that actually pays out on time. The interface is clean and not cluttered with useless ads. I’m really enjoying my time here so far. Visit jjjwin today.
If you love the thrill of the win, this is the place. The graphics are crisp and the gameplay is addictive. 777gamesbet is definitely my new favorite spot.
Had a blast playing here last night. The selection of games is massive and the rewards are genuinely exciting. Visit phokplaycasinologin for a great time.
Really friendly support team and the bonuses are actually fair. I had a great time exploring vnhay88aa yesterday.
Really impressed with the game variety here. Everything loads quickly and the customer support is helpful. Give 59ccom a try if you enjoy winning.
Quick access and no hassle with the account setup. It’s rare to find such a user-friendly site these days. Glad I found yy567login.
This place has a great community and the games are fair. I’ve had a few big wins here already and the experience was top notch. pkx555com
Really impressed with the selection here. It feels like a premium experience and the interface is very user-friendly. Highly recommend phnustarcebu for anyone looking for a solid platform.
The slot games here are so exciting and the jackpots are actually reachable. I had a great run last night at nibung88slot.
Such a friendly community and the support team is actually helpful. It feels more personal than other sites. Glad I found phjdlove.
The rewards system here is actually rewarding. I appreciate the daily login bonuses. krbwinners is the best way to start your gaming day.
The game variety is insane! I spent hours playing and didn’t get bored at all. Best experience so far at phjili44
If you are looking for a reliable spot with good odds, this is it. I’ve had a few decent wins already. caricuanslot is definitely my new go-to place.
Logging in is a breeze and the account verification was surprisingly quick. I really appreciate the efficiency of lotusdewalogin.
If you are looking for a secure way to play your favorite games then this is it. Everything feels safe and the support team is very helpful. Give jilibet178login a try.
Solid experience so far. The site loads quickly on my phone and the game selection is top notch. Give bds444 a try if you want a reliable site
The login process is seamless and I love how quickly I can get into the action. Best slot experience I have had in a while. Just visit slotaladinlogin and see for yourself.
The login process here is lightning fast. I hate waiting for pages to load, but this site is snappy and efficient. Definitely the best way to access ww777login.
Just finished the setup and everything is running perfectly. The installation process was straightforward and the rewards are legit. Go get it at jl777download now.
Really impressed with the variety of games here. Everything loads quickly and the customer support team is actually helpful. Highly recommend ff5555bet to everyone.
I really enjoy the atmosphere here. The winning streaks have been amazing lately and the registration was a breeze. Visit vngen88 for some action.
Perfect for those who want a seamless transaction process. The system is reliable and the odds are quite competitive. I am happy with idrupiahbet.
The graphics are amazing and the gameplay is just addictive. I had a great time winning some decent amounts yesterday. Love q444game so much.
Quick download and even quicker setup. I’m really enjoying the gameplay and the community vibe here is just awesome 55ccombetbaixar
Best customer support I have encountered so far. They solved my issue in minutes. Totally trust okbetnetlogin with my gaming needs.
The login process is secure and very straightforward. I appreciate how they handle user privacy and account security. I always use akunboslogin.
This is exactly what I was looking for. The promos are generous and the gameplay is genuinely exciting. My new favorite is 77pinas08